It did cause some amount of problems with things like a Shield spell making the caster effectively blind.I'm used to the 1e version of Rope Trick, that lasts for hours.
While I like this force-is-opaque for Leo's Hut it seems to defeat the best aspect of Wall of Force, that being to make an invisible immovable barrier for things to crash into at full speed.
The 2024 version has, at least, settled that issue by making it a 10 foot emanation rather than a dome.
I thought we were using the word "magic" in D&D to mean "spells". Other stuff is "supernatural". Didn't we agree on that?
Jeremy Crawford says that the (2014 Monk's) ki empowered strikes are described as magical, and therefor suppressed in an anti-magic field. I think you'll have to go get the dev team onboard.
I think all supernatural things should be suppressed in an antimagic field, so there you go.
Was there a tacit agreement in the thread? So sorry if so.
I think the problem with this is defining what is 'supernatural' in a setting. We can define it from our real worl perspective, of course, but a lot of things might be considered perfectly normal to people living in a fantastic world.
Literally every PC adventuring party is going to have someone with Dispel Magic available. It's really not much of a stretch that most packs of non-beast monsters would have the someone with the spell
Monk punches are magic, ergo, Monk casts FIST!
I think it’s a stretch to think that every random encounter is going to include a spell caster who has Dispel Magic.
